It’s a Podcast. But It’s Still Show Business.

What do successful podcasters understand that so many others don’t?

Knowing your subject is only part of the job. You have to give people a reason to listen, a reason to stay, and a reason to come back.

I work with some incredibly knowledgeable people. People who can explain the history behind a conflict, challenge a government narrative, and pull facts out of their heads that most of us would have to spend an afternoon looking up.

But put an expert in front of a microphone and you don’t automatically have a show.

You have an expert in front of a microphone.

As a producer, my job is to help turn that knowledge into something people want to watch. And yes, there is a difference. At the end of the day, this is a business. More specifically, it’s show business. Some people hear that and get uncomfortable. They think you’re asking them to dumb things down, act like a clown, or manufacture an argument.

I want people to hear what you have to say. That means we have to care about how you say it.

Start with the opening. Give me a reason to care. If your guest thinks we’re on the verge of another disastrous war, let’s get to that. We can work the credentials into the conversation. We don’t need to spend the first five minutes reading a biography while people reach for something else to watch. And once you get going, please don’t be so overprepared that there’s no room for a conversation. Know your subject. Do your homework. Have some questions ready. But look up from the damn notes.

I’ve heard a guest say something extraordinary, only to have the host respond with, “Okay, my next question is…” Wait. What? You’re just going to leave that sitting there? Ask what happened. Ask why. Ask how they know. If you didn’t understand the answer, there’s a pretty good chance somebody watching didn’t understand it either. Be ready for some improv. Sometimes the best part of the show is the part you couldn’t have planned.

That takes listening. It also takes enough confidence to let go of the idea that every minute needs to be under your control.

And for God’s sake, let some personality through.

Have a laugh. Tell the story. React when something surprises you. If a guest says something you don’t buy, ask them about it. You can push back without turning the conversation into a shouting match. People want to feel like they’re spending time with a human being. Give them somebody to connect with.

Look at Tucker Carlson, Joe Rogan, Theo Von, Ben Shapiro, Dave Rubin, Candace Owens, and plenty of others. You don’t have to agree with their politics—or even like their shows—to pay attention to what they do. They have distinct voices. Their audiences know what they’re coming for.

With Theo Von, part of the attraction is wondering where the hell the conversation might go. Rogan gives people room to talk, sometimes for hours. Shapiro has a pace and delivery his audience recognizes immediately. Different personalities. Different approaches. But the host is a big part of the draw. People may discover an episode because of the guest or the subject. Over time, you want them coming back because they want to spend that time with YOU.

And this goes well beyond political shows.

Take a travel podcast. If you’re telling me about some incredible place you visited, take me there. What did the street sound like? What could you smell coming out of that little restaurant? What happened when you got lost and couldn’t speak the language? Let me hear the excitement in your voice. If you stood somewhere and were overwhelmed by what you saw, help me feel some of that. You have this wonderful ability with audio to put a picture in somebody’s head. Use it. I should be able to close my eyes and imagine being there with you.

One example that stands out to me is Darryl Cooper’s

@MartyrMade podcast.

Cooper has a gift. Through his words, his pacing, and the emotion in his voice, he takes you inside the story he’s telling. He gives you a sense of the people involved. Their fears. Their circumstances. The decisions they faced. He knows when to slow down and let something land. That’s a skill worth studying. Listen to how a storyteller holds your attention, even when there’s nothing on a screen.

Then look at shows you may be less familiar with.

Jack Rhysider’s Darknet Diaries takes hacking and cybersecurity and makes them accessible through stories. You don’t have to work in cybersecurity to get caught up in what happened. Rhysider describes building the show to profitability and eventually hiring people to help produce it. That’s a business growing out of a specific interest and an ability to make people care about it.

Acquired, with Ben Gilbert and David Rosenthal, produces deeply researched episodes about businesses and how they developed. That depth is a major part of what the show offers its audience.

The Rest Is History has built a following around historical storytelling, with success that has extended into books. Imagine pitching somebody on long conversations about history and hearing, “Nobody has the attention span for that anymore.” Well, apparently some people do.

People will give you their time when you give them something they value.

That’s why I’m skeptical when somebody insists every podcast needs to follow the same formula. Some conversations need room to wander. Some stories need a script. Some shows thrive on humor. Others hold you with the weight of what’s being said.

You have to figure out what works for your show. Copying somebody else’s mannerisms won’t do that for you.

Look at the major radio companies and their podcast businesses. iHeart has Stuff You Should Know. Audacy has partnerships with Office Ladies and Fly on the Wall. There’s commercial value in a familiar voice, good chemistry, a laugh, and a subject people want to spend time with. But you don’t need iHeart or Audacy to tell you that you’re allowed to try. You don’t need celebrity. You don’t need a network deal before you record your first episode. Those things can help with reach, resources, and sales. They don’t relieve you of having to make a good show.

And making a good show means paying attention to the audience.

“Like and subscribe” is fine. But what are you doing to make somebody want to? Read a thoughtful comment. Answer a question. Let a viewer challenge you. Give people something to look forward to—a recurring segment, a question you ask every guest, a running joke that happened naturally. Let them feel that they’re part of something. Then take the production seriously. Clean audio matters. Pacing matters. So does knowing when a point has been made and it’s time to move on.

If you rush through something important, the audience may never get a chance to absorb it. If you spend twenty minutes making the same point, they may leave before you finish.A producer asking you to slow down, tighten an opening, or follow up on an answer is trying to help your work reach people. We want the show to succeed, too. I want the substance. I want the knowledge. I want a conversation that leaves somebody better informed or thinking about something they hadn’t considered. I also want them to enjoy the experience enough to come back.

That’s where the business begins. Returning viewers. Recommendations. Memberships. Sponsors who see an audience that cares.

Trust yourself enough to get started. Have a point of view. Explore what interests you. Be willing to try something, watch it back, and admit where it needs work.

You can believe in yourself and still take a note.

Prepare, but leave room for a surprise. Listen to your guest. Have a laugh when there’s something to laugh about. Take the audience somewhere. There are plenty of people with microphones. Give people a reason to listen to yours.

Christopher Leonard
Founder & President – OMG Media Partners, LLC.

support@omgmediapartners.com